How to Improve Email Open Rates (Beyond Generic Advice)

Last updated on March 13th, 2025 at

If you’ve ever sent out an email campaign and received little to no engagement, you’re not alone. It’s frustrating, right? You spend time crafting the perfect email, only for it to end up lost in the void of inboxes. Well, the problem might not be what you think.

While the subject line is often seen as the star of the show, it’s only one piece of the puzzle. In reality, there are several hidden factors at play that determine whether or not your email will get opened—and it’s not just about having a catchy subject line.

When it comes to email marketing success, open rates are the foundation. After all, no one can read your email if they don’t open it, right?

But here’s the thing: Improving those open rates isn’t as simple as just tweaking a few words in the subject line. There’s a misconception floating around that the subject line is everything, but that’s far from the truth.

What most blog posts get wrong is focusing too narrowly on the subject line, while ignoring the bigger picture. Open rates aren’t solely about clever wordplay or clickbait. In fact, there are several key factors that actually have a far bigger impact on your email’s open rate—things like psychology, deliverability, sender reputation, timing, and personalization.

This guide will walk you through these crucial factors and help you understand how they all fit together. We’ll also break down the O.P.E.N. Formula—a simple, step-by-step approach that will boost your email open rates like never before. Ready to dive in? Let’s unlock the secret to better email engagement!

Understanding Email Open Rate Benchmarks

One of the first steps in improving your email marketing is understanding what a good email open rate looks like. If you don’t have a baseline, it’s like trying to hit a target without knowing where the bullseye is. So, let’s dive into how you can measure and track your open rates—and what the benchmarks are across different industries.

What is a Good Email Open Rate?

A “good” email open rate depends on many factors—your industry, the quality of your email list, and how well your emails are targeted. But in general, an average open rate of 20-30% is a solid starting point. If you’re hitting that mark, you’re doing well! But if your open rate is lower, don’t worry—you’ve got room for improvement, and that’s exactly what we’re here to help you with.

Average Open Rates by Industry

Open rates can vary significantly across different industries. Here’s a quick snapshot of average email open rates by industry (according to recent data):

As you can see, the Non-Profit sector tends to see higher open rates, while E-commerce emails can have lower rates. Your industry can guide your expectations and give you a clear idea of where you stand in comparison.

How to Measure and Track Your Open Rates (Best Tools)

Now, it’s time to put your measuring tools to work. Tracking your open rates is crucial to improving them. Here are some of the best tools to monitor your email performance:

1. MailerLite – A great tool for beginners and experts alike, offering simple, yet powerful analytics to track open rates and engagement.
2. Constant Contact – Offers clear insights into open rates and provides recommendations for improvement.
3. Sendinblue – Not only tracks open rates, but also helps with A/B testing.
4. ActiveCampaign – A robust platform for tracking and automating your email campaigns.
5. Campaign Monitor – Offers detailed reporting on open rates and click-through rates.

These tools will help you see exactly where your emails are performing well and where there’s room for improvement.

Action Step: Find Your Baseline Open Rate Before Implementing New Strategies

Before diving into new strategies, take a moment to find your baseline open rate. This is your starting point, and without it, you won’t know whether your efforts are making a difference.

You can easily find this number in your email marketing platform’s reporting section. Once you know your open rate, you’ll be able to see how much you’ve improved after implementing strategies from this guide. Think of it like setting a personal goal—you’ll have something concrete to work toward and measure against.

The Psychology of Email Opens: Why People Click (or Ignore) Emails

Have you ever wondered why some emails seem to grab your attention while others just blend into the background of your inbox? It’s not just about how they look; it’s about the psychology behind why people open—or ignore—certain emails. Humans are driven by specific psychological triggers, and understanding these triggers can be the key to boosting your open rates.

Let’s break down some of the most powerful psychological factors that influence whether your emails get opened or left unread.

The Curiosity Gap – Making Readers Feel They’re Missing Out

Curiosity is a powerful motivator. People hate the feeling of missing out on something, and when you create a sense of curiosity, they’re more likely to click on your email. The Zeigarnik Effect suggests that we are naturally inclined to complete unfinished tasks or seek closure when our curiosity is piqued.

When you use curiosity-driven subject lines, you’re playing into this primal urge to find out more. For example, a subject like “What’s the one thing you’re doing wrong in your email campaigns?” taps into curiosity, making readers want to know the answer.

Action Step: Use the “Curiosity + Cliffhanger” Formula

To harness curiosity, use subject lines that leave a bit of information missing—enough to make your audience feel like they’re missing out. For example:

• “This one trick could change your email open rates… Find out how!“
• “You won’t believe what happened when we tested this strategy!“

This simple formula will spark the curiosity gap, driving more opens.

Loss Aversion & FOMO – Why People Hate Missing Out

People are naturally wired to fear loss more than they desire gain. This psychological bias, known as loss aversion, means that we’re more motivated to avoid losing something than we are to gain something new. This fear can be a huge driver for email opens.

The fear of missing out (FOMO) plays directly into this. If your subject line hints at something exclusive, scarce, or time-sensitive, people will feel the need to act fast.

Action Step: Create Scarcity-Based Subject Lines

To tap into loss aversion and FOMO, try using scarcity tactics in your subject lines:

• “Only 3 spots left—Don’t miss out!“
• “Last chance for this exclusive offer!“

These subject lines trigger a sense of urgency, encouraging readers to open your email to avoid missing out.

Authority Bias – The Power of Credibility & Social Proof

People tend to trust experts, statistics, and well-known brands. This is known as authority bias—we are more likely to believe and follow what an authority figure says, even if we don’t know them personally. When you use credible sources or social proof in your subject lines, you’re more likely to gain the trust of your readers and encourage them to open your email.

Action Step: Add Authority References in Subject Lines

To make your emails more authoritative, mention respected sources or institutions. For example:

• “Harvard Study Says This Strategy Increases Engagement“
• “Top Industry Experts Recommend This Approach“

These subject lines draw on the trust people place in authoritative figures and can lead to higher open rates.

Reciprocity – How Giving First Increases Opens

Reciprocity is the idea that when you give something valuable to others, they feel inclined to return the favor. In email marketing, giving value upfront—whether it’s a helpful tip, a free resource, or an exclusive offer—can motivate your audience to open your email because they feel like they owe you something in return.

Action Step: Subject Line Template: “Here’s a Free Resource to Improve Your [Problem]”

When you lead with value, people are more likely to open your email and engage with it. Here’s a subject line formula you can use:

• “Here’s a free checklist to improve your email marketing“
• “Download this free guide to boost your sales“

This creates a sense of goodwill and gives readers a reason to open your email right away.

Inbox Positioning & Deliverability: How to Ensure Your Emails Get Seen

You could have the perfect subject line, an engaging email, and the best offer, but none of that matters if your email doesn’t even land in the inbox. If your email ends up in the Spam or Promotions folder, it might as well not exist. Ensuring that your emails land in the Primary inbox is crucial to maximizing open rates and engagement. Let’s break down how inbox positioning works and how you can make sure your emails get seen by your subscribers.

How Email Providers Decide Inbox Placement

When you send an email, email providers like Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo have algorithms that decide where your email should go: the Primary, Promotions, or Spam folder. Here’s a quick breakdown of the three main folders:

• Primary Folder: This is where your email should ideally land. It’s where people see personal and important emails.
• Promotions Folder: Emails that seem to be marketing-focused often get placed here. While it’s not the worst place for your email, it’s harder for readers to notice.
• Spam Folder: This is the dreaded place where your emails go if they appear suspicious or look like spam. If your email ends up here, it won’t be seen unless someone actively checks their Spam folder.

How Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo Filter Emails

Each provider uses its own set of algorithms to filter emails. However, most of them use the following criteria to decide where your email goes:

• Engagement Metrics: If your emails are opened, replied to, or marked as “important,” you’re more likely to land in the Primary folder.
• Reputation: A good sender reputation increases your chances of landing in the inbox.
• Content and Spammy Keywords: Using too many promotional words or links could trigger the Promotions or Spam folders.
• Frequency: Sending too many emails in a short period can increase the likelihood of being flagged as spam.

Action Step: Use Mail-Tester.com to Check Your Inbox Placement

Before you send out a campaign, it’s always a good idea to check your inbox placement. Mail-Tester.com is a free tool that lets you test your emails and see if they’re likely to end up in Spam or Promotions. It gives you a score based on your email’s content, subject line, and other factors, helping you improve before hitting “send.”

How to Improve Your Sender Reputation (The Hidden Open Rate Killer)

Your sender reputation is essentially a score that email providers assign you based on how trustworthy they believe you are. If your reputation is poor, your emails are more likely to land in the Spam or Promotions folder. Here’s what you can do to keep your sender reputation strong:

• Avoid Spam Complaints: Too many people marking your emails as spam will hurt your reputation.
• Consistent Sending: Don’t send too many emails at once or too infrequently. Find a balance that works for your audience.
• Clean Your Email List: Regularly remove inactive or invalid email addresses to prevent bounces.

How to Check Your Domain Reputation (Google Postmaster Tools)

To see how good your sender reputation is, you can use tools like Google Postmaster Tools. It gives you an overview of your email reputation, including spam rates and delivery issues.

Action Step: Set Up a Dedicated Email Sending Domain

One of the best ways to protect your reputation is to set up a dedicated email sending domain (e.g., [email protected]). This ensures that your marketing emails are separate from your regular communications and can help build trust with email providers.

How to Avoid Spam Triggers in Your Email Copy

Spam filters are constantly evolving, but there are still common words and practices that trigger them. Spam filters look for certain red flags, including specific words, excessive use of capital letters, or too many links.

Common Spam Trigger Words:

• 🚫 “Make money fast!”
• 🚫 “100% Free!”
• 🚫 “Click here now!”
• 🚫 “Guaranteed”
• 🚫 “Risk-free”

These types of words can make your email look suspicious to spam filters. It’s best to avoid them or use them sparingly.

Action Step: Test Your Email with GlockApps or Mail-Tester Before Sending

Before you hit “send,” always test your email to see if it contains any red flags. Tools like GlockApps and Mail-Tester let you run a test and evaluate if your email has any spammy characteristics. This will give you a chance to make adjustments before your email goes out to your list.

Subject Line Optimization: Writing Headlines That Get Clicked

Your subject line is the first impression your email makes on a reader. It’s the make-or-break moment where someone decides whether to open your email or ignore it. So, making it count is crucial. A well-crafted subject line can mean the difference between a click and a scroll. In this section, we’ll explore proven strategies for writing subject lines that get clicked.

The “4U Formula” for High-Converting Subject Lines

One of the most effective ways to write subject lines that capture attention is by following the 4U Formula: Useful, Urgent, Unique, and Ultra-Specific. When your subject line ticks all four boxes, you’re much more likely to grab your reader’s attention.

• Useful: Make it clear that your email provides value.
• Urgent: Create a sense of urgency that encourages immediate action.
• Unique: Stand out by offering something different from the norm.
• Ultra-Specific: Give your readers a clear idea of what they’ll get when they open your email.

Example: “How I Increased Email Open Rates by 37% Overnight”

This subject line is a perfect example because:

• Useful: It promises helpful information on improving email open rates.
• Urgent: The phrase “overnight” implies speed and immediate results.
• Unique: Personal success adds a unique touch.
• Ultra-Specific: It gives a concrete, measurable figure (37%) that makes the claim more believable.

Action Step: Rewrite Your Next Subject Line Using the 4U Framework

Before you send out your next email campaign, try writing your subject line with the 4U Formula in mind. It’s a quick exercise that can significantly improve your open rates. Ask yourself:

• Is it useful to the reader?
• Does it create a sense of urgency?
• Is it unique and different from other emails in their inbox?
• Is it ultra-specific, offering a clear benefit?

The Power of Emojis & Symbols (When to Use Them)

Emojis are more than just fun little images—they can actually increase open rates when used correctly. Studies show that emails with emojis in the subject line have higher engagement. Emojis help your email stand out in a crowded inbox and grab attention instantly. However, like anything, moderation is key. Too many emojis can make your email look unprofessional or spammy.

How Emojis Increase Open Rates

• They make your subject line eye-catching.
• They help convey emotion quickly.
• They can break up the text, making the subject line more visually appealing.

Best Emoji Practices for Subject Lines

• Use emojis that match the tone and content of your email. For example, if you’re offering a free resource, you might use 📚 or 🎁.
• Stick to 1-2 emojis in the subject line to avoid looking cluttered or unprofessional.
• Test different emojis to see which ones resonate best with your audience.

Example:

• 🎉 Special Offer: 50% Off Your Next Purchase!
• 📚 Free Guide: How to Boost Your Email Open Rates

Using Power Words That Trigger Emotions

Certain power words have the ability to trigger emotions and inspire action. These words resonate with readers on a psychological level and make them more likely to click. Power words can convey urgency, exclusivity, or mystery, which prompt the reader to open the email right away.

High-Converting Power Words:

• Secrets
• Insider
• Proven
• Exclusive
• Free
• Unlock
• Guaranteed
• Limited
• Instant
• Easy
• Step-by-Step

For example, “Unlock these exclusive tips” is much more enticing than “Check out these tips.” The word exclusive makes the reader feel like they’re getting something special.

Action Step: Add at Least One Power Word in Your Next Subject Line

For your next email campaign, try incorporating at least one power word from the list above. See how it transforms your subject line, making it more compelling and emotionally charged. Here’s a couple of examples:

• “Exclusive Offer: 30% Off Your First Purchase“
• “Proven Strategies to Double Your Open Rates“

 Personalization & Segmentation: Why “Hey [First  Name]” Isn’t Enough

In the world of email marketing, personalization is no longer just about adding a first name to the subject line. While calling someone by their name might have worked once upon a time, it’s no longer enough to drive engagement. Today, the most effective emails are the ones that truly resonate with the recipient—those that deliver the right message at the right time. In this section, we’ll dive into behavioral triggers, AI-powered personalization, and location-based strategies to help you level up your email marketing.

Behavioral Triggers: Sending the Right Email at the Right Time

Behavioral triggers are actions that prompt you to send an email based on specific behaviors or interactions. These are powerful because they’re relevant to the individual’s actions or interests, making your email much more likely to be opened and acted upon. Rather than sending a generic message to everyone, behavioral triggers ensure that your email feels timely and personalized based on what the recipient has done.

Examples of Behavior-Based Email Triggers:

• Abandoned Cart Emails: These are triggered when a user adds items to their cart but doesn’t complete the purchase. A simple reminder email can bring them back and increase conversions. For example:
  • “Looks like you left something behind! Complete your purchase now and save 10%.”
• Welcome Sequence Based on Signup Source: When someone signs up through a specific channel (like your website or social media), you can send them a welcome email tailored to that source. For example:
  • “Welcome to our community! Here’s a special discount just for our Instagram followers!”
• Re-Engagement Emails for Inactive Subscribers: If someone hasn’t interacted with your emails in a while, you can send a targeted re-engagement email to bring them back into the fold. For example:
  • “We miss you! Here’s a 20% off coupon to welcome you back.”

Dynamic Content & AI-Powered Personalization

AI-powered personalization is transforming email marketing, making it more effective and tailored than ever before. While basic personalization (like using the recipient’s name) is still common, dynamic content goes far beyond this. Using AI and behavioral data, you can now send hyper-targeted emails that adjust based on the recipient’s behavior, preferences, and even past interactions.

Example: Personalized Product Recommendations in Emails

One great example of AI-driven personalization is sending product recommendations based on a recipient’s past browsing or purchase history. If a customer bought a pair of shoes from your store, your next email could feature other related products, like socks, shoe care items, or accessories. For example:

• “Since you loved your new sneakers, we think you’ll love these matching accessories!”

This type of dynamic content creates a truly personalized experience for the recipient, making them feel like you understand their needs and preferences.

The Power of Location & Time-Based Personalization

Another game-changer in personalization is location-based and time-based targeting. Sending emails based on a recipient’s time zone ensures that they receive your message at an optimal time, when they are most likely to engage. This small but impactful change can drastically improve your open rates.

How to Send Emails Based on Time Zones for Better Open Rates:

• If your audience is spread across different time zones, segmenting your email list by location can help you send your emails at the most effective time for each recipient. For example:
  • If someone is in New York and someone else is in Los Angeles, sending emails at 9 AM in their respective time zones increases the chances they’ll see it in their inbox when they’re most active.

Sending timely, location-based emails gives your audience the feeling that you’re not only paying attention to their needs but also respecting their time.

Action Step: Segment Your Email List Based on Geography

For your next email campaign, take the time to segment your email list by geography. This can be done through your email marketing platform by using location data or asking subscribers to select their location during the sign-up process. Once you have your segments, you can send targeted, time-sensitive emails that will have a much higher chance of being opened.

Timing & Frequency: When & How Often to Send Emails

Timing and frequency are often the unsung heroes of email marketing. Even with great content and personalization, if your email doesn’t land at the right time, it may never be seen. The right timing can dramatically improve your open rates, while the right frequency ensures that you’re staying in front of your audience without overwhelming them. In this section, we’ll break down the best times to send emails, how to find your sweet spot with frequency, and tips for testing and adjusting your approach.

Best Days & Times to Send Emails (Backed by Data)

When it comes to email timing, it’s important to know when your audience is most likely to engage. Research consistently shows that there are certain days and times when your emails are more likely to be opened.

General Best Days & Times to Send Emails:

• Best Days: Tuesdays and Thursdays consistently outperform other days in terms of open rates. These days are far enough from the weekend to avoid getting lost in a busy inbox, but close enough to the start of the week when people are back at their desks.
• Best Times: Emails tend to get higher engagement between 8 AM – 10 AM and 4 PM – 6 PM. People are usually checking their emails first thing in the morning or as they wind down at the end of the day.

Why These Times Work:

• 8 AM – 10 AM: People are fresh and checking emails at the start of their day.
• 4 PM – 6 PM: People often check their inboxes before they finish work for the day, catching up on what they missed earlier.

Action Step: Test Sending Your Next Email at an Unusual Time (e.g., 9:47 AM)

Sometimes, trying something out of the ordinary can yield surprising results. For example, test sending your email at a time like 9:47 AM, which can stand out from the usual round-hour send times. You might find that this small variation gets your email noticed more. Keep testing different times to find what works best for your audience.

How to Avoid Over-Sending or Under-Sending Emails

The frequency of your email campaigns is just as important as timing. It’s easy to fall into the trap of either over-sending or under-sending, and both can lead to problems.

Signs You’re Sending Too Many Emails:

• Unsubscribes & Complaints: If people are unsubscribing or marking your emails as spam, it’s a sign that you’re overwhelming them with emails. It’s important to strike a balance so that your audience doesn’t feel like you’re crowding their inbox.

• Fatigue: When you send too many emails, your audience may stop engaging because they feel bombarded. You want your emails to be anticipated, not dreaded.

Signs You’re Not Sending Enough Emails:

• Low Engagement: If your email open rates and click-through rates are low, you might not be emailing enough. A lack of communication can cause subscribers to forget about you, leading to missed opportunities.

• Stagnant Growth: If you’re not consistently sending out content, you miss the chance to nurture your audience and keep your brand top of mind.

Action Step: Create a Consistent Sending Schedule

Consistency is key when it comes to email frequency. Whether you choose to send emails weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly, sticking to a predictable schedule helps build trust and anticipation with your audience.

Here’s a basic guideline:

• Weekly emails: Great for businesses with active promotions or blog content.
• Bi-weekly emails: Perfect for brands that want to stay in front of their audience without overwhelming them.
• Monthly emails: Best for brands with less frequent updates or for newsletters that compile larger amounts of information

Re-Engagement & Email List Cleaning: Keeping Open Rates High

An email list is a valuable asset for any business, but to keep your open rates high, it’s essential to maintain a clean and engaged list. If your subscribers aren’t opening your emails or engaging with your content, it’s time to re-engage and clean your list. In this section, we’ll cover how to identify and remove inactive subscribers and how to re-engage those who have slipped away.

How to Identify & Remove Inactive Subscribers

When your subscribers become inactive, they don’t just stop engaging—they can actually hurt your sender reputation and affect deliverability. If too many emails go unopened, email providers like Gmail or Outlook will start to mark your emails as spam or send them to the Promotions folder. This leads to lower open rates and decreased visibility for your future campaigns.

Why Low Engagement Damages Your Sender Reputation:

• Spam Filters: Providers look at your engagement rates (opens, clicks) to determine if your emails are worth delivering. If your engagement drops, your reputation with providers drops too, meaning your emails are less likely to get delivered to the inbox.
• List Bloat: A large number of inactive or unengaged subscribers can skew your metrics, making it harder to assess the true effectiveness of your campaigns.

Action Step: Use Email Automation to Tag Inactive Subscribers

The easiest way to manage inactive subscribers is to use email automation to tag or segment them. Most email platforms like Mailerlite, Mailchimp, or ConvertKit offer automation tools that help you automatically tag people who haven’t opened your emails in a certain period, such as 30, 60, or 90 days. Once you’ve tagged these subscribers, you can target them with re-engagement campaigns or, if needed, remove them from your list.

How to Win Back Lost Subscribers (With a Re-Engagement Campaign)

If your subscribers have gone inactive, don’t give up on them just yet! You can win them back with a re-engagement campaign. A well-crafted re-engagement sequence can remind them of your value and re-establish your connection.

3 – Email Re-Engagement Sequence:

A re-engagement sequence should include multiple attempts to bring inactive subscribers back. Here’s a simple 3-email sequence to help you win back lost subscribers:

• Email 1: “Still Interested? Here’s What You’ve Missed…”
  This email aims to remind your subscribers of what they’ve missed and the value of staying on your list. Highlight your best content, offers, or recent updates to spark their interest again.

  • Example:
    Subject Line: “Still Interested? Here’s What You’ve Missed…”
  • Body:
    “We’ve been busy! From exclusive offers to insightful blog posts, here’s what you may have missed while you were away… [Insert links to top content]. We’d love for you to re-engage with us—here’s a special discount just for you!”

• Email 2: “We’ll Miss You! Final Chance to Stay Subscribed”
  If your first email doesn’t get a response, send a second email that creates a sense of urgency and makes them feel like they’re about to miss out.

  • Example:
    Subject Line: “We’ll Miss You! Final Chance to Stay Subscribed”
  • Body:
    “We noticed you haven’t been opening our emails lately, and we just wanted to check in. We’ve loved having you on our list, but if you’re no longer interested, no hard feelings! Here’s one last chance to stay with us. [Link to re-engage].”

• Email 3: “We’re Removing You (Unless You Click Here)”
  If there’s still no response, send a final email that gives them one last chance to stay on your list. This email should convey the finality of the situation—either they engage, or they’re removed.

  • Example:
    Subject Line: “We’re Removing You (Unless You Click Here)”
  • Body:
    “This is it! If you don’t click below to stay subscribed, we’ll have to say goodbye and remove you from our list. [Link to stay subscribed]. Don’t miss out on future updates!”

These emails should be spaced out over a period of time (usually one to two weeks) to give your subscribers enough time to respond. The goal is to re-engage those who are still interested while removing those who no longer care, keeping your list fresh and your engagement high.

The O.P.E.N Formula: A Step-by-Step Blueprint to Higher Open Rates

.